Commentary on Ivannikov2011

Introduction

This is a note only for my own rememberance on “Ivannikov, Maxim V., Mutsuyuki Sugimori, and Rodolfo R. Llinás. “Calcium clearance and its energy requirements in cerebellar neurons.” Cell calcium 47.6 (2010): 507-513.”
Note: “Active transport” is the ATP-consuming transportation of ions from/to intracellular/extracellular by pumps, “Passive transport” is the voltage-dependent transportation of ions through channels.

Results

1. Inhibitor of ATP

1.1 Results on the paper

2 types of ATP inhibitor increased delays by 66±25%, 66±15%.

1.2 Conclusion

ATP production, mainly done via glycolysis process, delays Calcium clearance by 66%.

2. Inhibitor of NCX

It showed almost no delay, which means almost nothing. There are other paths Calcium go through.
Postscript on 2026/1/22: It seems to implicate the passive transport via TRPM family have the considerable contribution to the Calcium clearance. 

3. Inhibition of PMCA by La3+ 

3.1 Results on the paper

It delayed the clearance by 64±21%.

3.2 Discussion & Conclusion

It matches the delay caused by ATP inhibitor. It suggests that PMCA is the dominant active transporter on the Calcium clearance.
Postscript on 2026/1/22: It turned out that La3+ inhibits TRPM family, but since adding La3+ disturbs the voltage, the impact on clearance delay needs further analysis.

4 Discussion & Conclusion (in my opinion)

4.1 Estimation based on above discussion

Based on the results on the paper, the Calcium transport capacity is roughly estimated as Active transport: 40%, Passive transport: 60%.
Postscript on 2026/1/22: Since this estimate is based only on ATP-inhibition result, it stands.

4.2 Model-Elaboration using the knowledge on La3+

Turned out that La3+ inhibits both PMCA and TRPM(Google Gemini conversation here), the estimation turns out to require the further analysis, e.g. the multiple regression analysis. 
Table 1.
Inhibitors/Target PMCA
(Active transport)
TRPM(Passive) NCX(Passive) Delay multiplier sdv
DOG 0 1 1 1.66 0.25
IAA 0 1 1 1.65 0.15
La3+ 0 0 1 1.64 0.21
Sucrose/noNa 1 1 0 1.079 0.0075

Disclaimer

I don’t know the methodology on each experimental operation is right or not.

Google Gemini Estimation

Not going along with my estimation, Google Gemini has estimated that Active transportː Over 90%, Passive transportː Approx. 8%. Conversation here.

コメント

タイトルとURLをコピーしました